forum

Hi!

I have a light scene that simply turn Off a set of lights (2 lamps operated by a Fibaro multiswitch).
I have a group that simply includes that light scene only for ON events.
Finally i have a bind between other light and the group (this is because you cannot bind a light with a light scene).

When i turn on the second light, al the lights in the scene are turned Off. Great!... This works fine when i use phisical buttons... But when the lights in the scene are On and the second light is on... When i switch Off the second light... The lights include in the light scene are turned Off tooo... Only when i use virtual button in the ha ui. That is a Strange behaviour.

Another case: if a build a similar conbination to do the opositte action... (Turn Off the second light when i turn on any light in the light scene) when i turn on any light in the light scene i described all lights (the second light but the lights in the light scene ) are turned Off todo

This is really weird... Is this a bug?

Hi PoltoS!
Have you seen this post? Could you please help me with this?

Quite hard to follow.... Excuse. May be you can describe it a bit more clearly with modules name, exact actions. Or a video to reproduce

Hi PoltoS
Thanks to LogicalRule module, i have simplified the scenario with problems.

I have a LightScene to switch off Light 1. We could name this scene "Scene1_off"
I have a LogicalRule with the following configuration:
-condition: when Light2 is On
-action: activate Scene1_off

I have performed several tests with diferent results:

Test1
Inicial status: Light1 On. Light2 off.
Action: manual switch on of Light2 (using wall switch or using UI web button).
Result: light1 is automatically switched Off.
Evaluation: OK

Test2
Inicial status: Ligh1 and Light2 are On
Action: Manual switch Off of Light2 (using wall switch)
Result: nothing happens automatically.
Evaluation: Ok

Test3
Initial status: Light1 and Light2 are on.
Action: switch Off of Light2 using UI button
Result: Light1 is automatically switched Off!
Evaluation: wrong behaviour. The result must be the dame as test2.

PoltoS could you review? Itv very Strange!
I have all fibaro relays.
Thanks

Hard to reproduce... tried - all in vain. If you are able, please have a look on it with a debugger. Or add a lot of console.logJS(...) in LogicalRules/index.js

Many thanks for your support, anyway! I will try to debug your code (i will do my best )

may be you can give remote access to the box?

hi PoltoS

i have used console.log with no success... i can´t see anything. How console.logJS works??

Maybe, when the module is triggered by a change of state of the switch used in the binary condition, the module is not recovering properly the actual state of the device and maybe is considering a "on" state when is "off"... but i dont know why ¿?

Thanks!
Sergio

Hard to interpret your data. May be you can use the debugger tool?

Ha ha ha i'm sorry... I'm using chrome browser javascript console. Could you recomend me another way to debug?
As i said i put a lot of console.log ("xxxx") but i couldnt see anything.